Friday
24 July 2026
Year V
INDEPENDENT INTERNATIONAL DAILY
Friday, 24 July 2026 · Anno V
Between Spirituality and Control: The Dark Side of New Forms of Ecclesial Belonging
Catholic Church24 July 2026

Between Spirituality and Control: The Dark Side of New Forms of Ecclesial Belonging

Collaboration between lay people and religious is growing as the vocations crisis deepens. Some experiences foster communion; others lead to dependence, concentrations of power and intrusion into private life.

Listen to the article
—:——
Subscribe →

The vocations crisis is prompting many religious institutes to look beyond their own communities for the people and support they can no longer find within them. As a result, partnerships with lay people are becoming increasingly common, taking widely differing forms and involving varying commitments and degrees of affiliation. Some of these experiences bear genuine fruit. Others create an ambiguous space in which the boundaries between consecrated and lay life become blurred, often with painful consequences for both.

The relationship between religious orders and the lay faithful has formed part of the Church’s history for centuries. Third orders, secular oblates and confraternities have enabled men and women living in the world to draw on the spirituality of a religious family. Today, however, this relationship must be considered in the light of a more mature ecclesial understanding of the lay vocation. The Second Vatican Council restored due importance to the baptismal dignity of the faithful and to their mission in the world; the same perspective runs through Evangelii gaudium.

THIS ARTICLE ONLY
0,99€one time

Unlock and read this article in full. No subscription, no renewal.

ALL ARTICLES
BEST VALUE
8€/month

Unlimited access to all Silere non possum journalism, audio included.

SUBSCRIBE
SUPPORT SILERE NON POSSUM

If this article is online, it is also thanks to your support.

Silere non possum chooses to make most of its investigations and content freely accessible, because independent journalism must be able to reach everyone.

Supporting our work means allowing us to continue verifying, reporting and publishing what others would prefer to keep hidden.

SUPPORT USSUBSCRIBE
Related articles
Beyond Obedience: What Maturity for the Priesthood Really Means
Catholic Church
Beyond Obedience: What Maturity for the Priesthood Really Means
Notre Dame’s Shameful Blueprint for Policing Seminarians’ Consciences
Catholic Church
Notre Dame’s Shameful Blueprint for Policing Seminarians’ Consciences
When Religious Life Mistakes Recruitment for Renewal
Catholic Church
When Religious Life Mistakes Recruitment for Renewal